Two dishes are better than none. At least according to Congress. House members last week seemed to condone EchoStar's strategy of relegating some TV channels to second-class status, forcing customers to install a second dish if they want every local channel in their market.
Broadcasters hate the practice, which they say violates the spirit of the 1999 "carry one/carry all" law requiring satellite operators to offer all local channels in a market or none at all. EchoStar circumvents that by putting the most popular channels on a customer's primary dish and installing a second dish free for the other stations—but only on request.
Outlawing the practice is critical for broadcasters. They hope to tack a ban onto legislation reauthorizing the law governing satellite carriage of broadcast channels, which expires Dec. 31. Save for a couple of congressmen, members of the House Telecommunications Subcommittee largely ignored the spat during a hearing on renewing the carriage law.
The comments of Rep. Rick Boucher (D-Va.) were chilling to broadcasters. He appeared to represent lawmakers' sentiments when he lauded EchoStar for putting some channels on a second dish rather than allow bandwidth constraints to eliminate local service in 30 of its 107 markets.
"A completely satisfactory answer; I applaud your approach," Boucher said to EchoStar general counsel David Moskowitz.
Even DirecTV President Eddie Hartenstein likes having the option of a second dish. DirecTV may one day be forced by spectrum limitations to carry some local channels on a second dish, he said. "You can't deny the laws of physics."
Only New York Democrat Elliot Engel took a stand against the practice. He said it puts public and Hispanic stations in his state at risk of being ignored by the majority of EchoStar subscribers. Most subscribers don't want a second dish installed, even though it comes free with their local package. "Most of [the stations'] customers are paying for channels they aren't getting. I don't believe this is fair."
For his part, WDBJ Roanoke, Va., General Manager Bob Lee said dividing stations between top- and lower-rated outlets is the real problem because customers won't install a second dish for less-popular channels. "Put them all on the second dish if you like. As long as they're in the same place, we don't care."
The television industry's top news stories, analysis and blogs of the day.